I think bottles and binkys are one of those things - some parents think they know best. Both of my kids loved their bottles. They especially loved a nice cool bottle of milk to help lull them into sleepy wonderland. I didn't push the issue because they don't suck their thumb and they didn't use a binky. If my kids wanted a bottle of milk fo comfort, who was I to refuse them. It's MILK! I know, I know. Some of you are screaming about their teeth. But somehow that always seemed to be the least of my worries.
I don't remember the age that Stewart voluntarily quit the bottle - but he did. I think he was right around 2. He loved his milk. I have memories of finding nasty curdled bottles of milk that had fallen under or behind his bed. Gross. There is no easy and non-disgusting way to get that big curdled chunk out of a bottle.
Parker wasn't quite ready yet. Keep in mind, he will be 2 in about an hour and a half(it's March 30, straight up midnight). Our challenge with Parker was that he wanted his bottle all day. He had no problems with sippy cups and even regular cups. He wanted the comfort of his bottle all day. To be completely honest, it became a big pain in the ass. He would go through 5-6 gallons of milk a week. Which was the other problem. He didn't ever want to eat. He wanted his bottle over food. His pediatrician, whom I trust, said some kids chose to get their calories from milk. He said we shouldn't worry about it if he is growing and developing. So i let it slide for a while.
Did I mention that it was a pain in the ass? It was. He wanted milk SEVERAL times during the night. Sometimes having 4 bottles of milk in the night - which always involved a diaper change or he would wake up with soaked pajamas which meant that I had to not only change his diaper but would also need to wash his jammies, the sheets, the mattress pad, his blankets, etc.
Which I did. I did this. I didn't want to deprive him of milk because he refused to eat. I mean, the doctor said, "some kids like to get their calories from milk and it's ok . . . " This is how it went, he would go to bed at 8:30 with a bottle. During the 11 o'clock hour he would wake up cying and want another. Same thing between 2-3. Same thing during the 6 o'clock hour. As you can see, mom and dad weren't getting much sleep.
This was all about to change.
One night he started crying. I rolled my tired carcass out of the bed in the middle of a very very very very cold night. Same routine, Parker cry = give me milk! So I go in there and he's fussing around his bed. While I am re-tucking him in, he's saying, "baba pwease." (First let me say, I probably should have cut him off when he was able to say baba. Some books say not to do bottles after the first year.) I lay him on his pillow and try to dig out his blankets that he is all tangled up in when I discover that he is laying on top of a full bottle. He was too lazy to roll over in his bed to get a drink from a bottle that he was laying on that was making him uncomfortable. Instead of rolling over, he chose to cry out, knowing that I would zombie stumble my way into his room to cater to his late night/early morning needs. That irritated me but I tucked him in and kissed him. He did the exact same thing 2-3 more times when I finally said, "NO MORE!"
So 2 weeks ago, I woke up on a Monday morning and put all of his bottles up. If he was thirsty, he could drink from a regular cup or a sippy cup. NO MORE BOTTLES. I told Bill it was going to be a few rough nights but it would pay off if we could get through the first week. We even put Stewart up in the guest bed room. Naptime and the first night were a bit rough for him. He cried and screamed and demanded, "BABA! BABA PWEEEEAAASE!" The second night was a little easier and the third night was even easier, and so on. Dare I say it, I don't want to jinx it. Our little fuss bucket is sleeping through the night. Occasionally, he will wake up during the 4 o'clock hour and cry and I'll give him a sip of milk from his sippy cup and he will go right back to sleep.
AND - even better! He's eating now! HE EATS! For the longest time, Parker was the incredible not eating kid but now he eats. He is still picky about what he eats but he will eat. And a little boy with a full tummy is a little boy that takes a good nap and sleeps well at night.
TA! DA!